top of page

Custom Cookies


Our cookies are perfect for sharing love and thoughtfulness on any occasion, and have been shipped to nearly every state in the US. Are you ready to share the love? This page will walk you through the process of ordering your cookies. Still have questions, or not seeing what you need? Feel free to email us and we'll get back to you as soon as possible.

  • Facebook
  • TikTok
  • Instagram
When you order a dozen cookies, you'll get (at least) one pound of cookies in various shapes and sizes. 
Our delicious cookies are baked fresh and can be locally delivered ($5), shipped ($10), or picked up at our home bakery (free).
  1. Click on the Shop Now button, which will take you to the ordering page.

  2. Decide how much you'd like to spend. There are three price point packages, and all are lovely, but the more you're willing to spend, the more customized the artwork will be. Take a look at our "Style Guide" for more information about the tiered pricing system.

  3. Let us know what you would like... Flavors, dietary restrictions, colors, styles, theme, and links to artwork you love are all helpful. The order form has plenty of ideas and guides to spark your creativity.

  4. Tell us when you would like the cookies ready for shipping, pick up, or local delivery. We don't bake the cookies until a few days before you want them, so you can order far in advance.

  5. Email us if you have questions or your requests don't fully fit on the form. Likewise, if we have questions, we'll contact you.


A Quick Guide to Ordering Cookies

The current queue is 2 weeks for decorated cookies, and 1 week for Gingerbread Kits and Cookie Decorating Kits. Please allow fourteen days from the time that you order until custom cookies are ready for pickup, delivery, or shipping date. We do not ship on Sundays.


We apologize, but our emergency cookie option is currently not available due to high seasonal demand.

Current Cookie Queue

Current Available Flavors

Sugar Cookie

A crowd-pleasing classic with a soft, buttery, flavor. Just five simple ingredients.

Lemon Poppy Seed

Tart, yet earthy. Give your taste buds a jump start with this delicious variation.

Mexican Hot Chocolate

A dark chocolate cookie with cinnamon overtones and a touch of chili powder.


A holiday classic! Our recipe is deliciously authentic in flavor.

Please be aware that, although we clean surfaces, utensils and cookware thoroughly before baking our allergen-free cookies, there is still a chance of cross-contamination. If you have concerns about nut or gluten contamination, we recommend seeking out a nut or gluten free bakery.
Heart Cookies

Would you prefer to

Bake your own?

We got your back! Visit E's Recipes to learn all of Elizebeth's secrets for cut out cookies, royal icing, and spice mixes!

bottom of page